You know you're not the first...

There's a fake Aston Martin used car advert currently doing the rounds on Facebook, Twitter and Google+. Although it's a fake (a funny one in my opinion) I was surprised to find that it's based on a real advert for BMW in 2008 which really was copied, with a twist, by another company in 2009.

 

aston-martin.jpg

Now obviously, this sort of advert pretty much ignores (and rightly so) the guidelines I usually stick to when putting an Ad together (see my 'how-to' post on Constructing a Press Adverts) but it does raise the interesting question of what the tipping point is between appropriate and inappropriate uses of sexual imagery to sell a product that isn't directly sexual in nature.

I don't think there are hard and fast rules one can use here. For what it's worth I think that in this context it works but you do need a pretty strong existing brand image to weather any backlash that "this sort of thing" might generate.

BMW and (fake) Aston Martin do, a small company however might end up being swamped the by negative impression this could generate amongst those who have no other reference points for a brand.

All of which makes the twist a used car dealership in Ontario, Canada put on the original BMW advert all the more interesting.

The 'original' 2008 BMW advert and the interesting 2009 copy are below for comparison.

 

bmw2.png